ISM PN 3.1 vs Selle SMP TRK Large

Two saddles contenders, one winner. Here are the differences that matter and what to buy.

ISM PN 3.1

ISM

ISM PN 3.1

VS
Selle SMP TRK Large

Selle SMP

Selle SMP TRK Large

Comparison hexagon

Comparison hexagonEditorial rating of ISM PN 3.1 versus Selle SMP TRK Large across six criteriaPressurereliefComfortLightnessRacepositionBreak-inValue
Comparison hexagon
CriterionISM PN 3.1Selle SMP TRK Large
Pressure relief98/10088/100
Comfort75/10090/100
Lightness55/10045/100
Race position80/10045/100
Break-in35/10080/100
Value55/10060/100

GranFondoTemple editorial rating (0–100) based on each product’s pros and cons. Not lab measurements.

At-a-glance comparison

Swipe →
ProductPriceKey strengthKey weakness
ISM PN 3.1
ISMISM PN 3.1Our pick
196,42 €Almost fully removes perineal pressure thanks to its split designRequiere periodo de adaptación, la forma es muy distinta a un sillín tradicionalSee on Amazon →
Selle SMP TRK Large
Selle SMPSelle SMP TRK Large
60,49 €Deep central channel that relieves perineal pressureMás pesado que los sillines orientados a competiciónSee on Amazon →

Our verdict

Buy the ISM PN 3.1. It is our pick over the Selle SMP TRK Large: Almost fully removes perineal pressure thanks to its split design.

See ISM PN 3.1 on Amazon →
Our pickISM PN 3.1

ISM

ISM PN 3.1

Split, noseless saddle that fully removes perineal pressure, aimed at riders who suffer recurring discomfort on long rides or in very aggressive positions.

Strengths

  • Almost fully removes perineal pressure thanks to its split design
  • Well suited to aero or triathlon positions

Weaknesses

  • Requiere periodo de adaptación, la forma es muy distinta a un sillín tradicional
196,42 €
See ISM PN 3.1 on Amazon →
Selle SMP TRK Large

Selle SMP

Selle SMP TRK Large

Wide SMP-line saddle with the brand's signature anatomic shape and deep central channel, in a Large fit geared toward long-distance comfort rather than a race position.

Strengths

  • Deep central channel that relieves perineal pressure
  • Wide base, comfortable in the more upright positions typical of gran fondo riding

Weaknesses

  • Más pesado que los sillines orientados a competición
60,49 €
See Selle SMP TRK Large on Amazon →

Frequently asked questions

ISM PN 3.1 or Selle SMP TRK Large: which is better?

Buy the ISM PN 3.1. It is our pick over the Selle SMP TRK Large: Almost fully removes perineal pressure thanks to its split design.

When does it make sense to choose Selle SMP TRK Large?

Choose Selle SMP TRK Large if this is what you value most: Deep central channel that relieves perineal pressure.

More comparisons

As Amazon Associates we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.