Withings Body Comp vs Garmin Index S2

Two body-composition scales contenders, one winner. Here are the differences that matter and what to buy.

Withings Body Comp

Withings

Withings Body Comp

VS
Garmin Index S2

Garmin

Garmin Index S2

At-a-glance comparison

Swipe →
ProductPriceRatingKey strengthKey weakness
Withings Body Comp
WithingsWithings Body CompOur pick
199,95 €4.5 / 5ECG and visceral fat in the same scale, no separate chest strap neededNo segmental per-limb composition, unlike the Body ScanSee on Amazon →
Garmin Index S2
GarminGarmin Index S2
138,51 €4.6 / 5Syncs directly with Garmin Connect, no intermediate appNo ECG or segmental body composition like the top-tier Withings modelsSee on Amazon →

Our verdict

Buy the Withings Body Comp. It is our pick over the Garmin Index S2: ECG and visceral fat in the same scale, no separate chest strap needed.

See Withings Body Comp on Amazon →
Our pickWithings Body Comp

Withings

Withings Body Comp

WiFi-connected scale with full body analysis (weight, body fat, muscle mass, water) and cardiovascular tracking, for up to 8 users. Through the Health Mate app it exports to Strava or Apple Health/Google Fit, crossing weight and body composition with gran fondo training load with no manual entry.

Strengths

  • ECG and visceral fat in the same scale, no separate chest strap needed
  • Exports to Strava, Apple Health and Google Fit via Health Mate
  • Good balance of price and features compared with the Body Scan

Weaknesses

  • No segmental per-limb composition, unlike the Body Scan
199,95 €★ 4.5
See Withings Body Comp on Amazon →
Garmin Index S2

Garmin

Garmin Index S2

Garmin's smart scale with direct WiFi sync to Garmin Connect: weight, BMI, body fat, muscle and bone mass, body water and visceral fat, plus skin temperature trend. Recognises up to 16 users and adds your weight straight into your training history without any intermediate app.

Strengths

  • Syncs directly with Garmin Connect, no intermediate app
  • Automatic recognition of up to 16 users
  • Weight data links straight into your training and load history in Garmin

Weaknesses

  • No ECG or segmental body composition like the top-tier Withings models
138,51 €★ 4.6
See Garmin Index S2 on Amazon →

Frequently asked questions

Withings Body Comp or Garmin Index S2: which is better?

Buy the Withings Body Comp. It is our pick over the Garmin Index S2: ECG and visceral fat in the same scale, no separate chest strap needed.

When does it make sense to choose Garmin Index S2?

Choose Garmin Index S2 if this is what you value most: Syncs directly with Garmin Connect, no intermediate app.

More comparisons

As Amazon Associates we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.