Garmin Edge 840 vs Hammerhead Karoo 3

Two GPS bike computers contenders, one winner. Here are the differences that matter and what to buy.

Garmin Edge 840

Garmin

Garmin Edge 840

VS
Hammerhead Karoo 3

Hammerhead

Hammerhead Karoo 3

Comparison hexagon

Comparison hexagonEditorial rating of Garmin Edge 840 versus Hammerhead Karoo 3 across six criteriaBatteryMapsDisplayEase of useValueCompact
Comparison hexagon
CriterionGarmin Edge 840Hammerhead Karoo 3
Battery80/10065/100
Maps88/10092/100
Display70/10095/100
Ease of use80/10080/100
Value70/10065/100
Compact80/10070/100

GranFondoTemple editorial rating (0–100) based on each product’s pros and cons. Not lab measurements.

At-a-glance comparison

Swipe →
ProductPriceKey strengthKey weakness
Garmin Edge 840
GarminGarmin Edge 840Our pick
783,98 €Physical buttons plus touchscreen, handy with gloves and in the rainSmaller screen: the map is harder to read at descending speedSee on Amazon →
Hammerhead Karoo 3
HammerheadHammerhead Karoo 3
434,54 €Bright, sharp touchscreen, the best map experience in the categoryShorter battery life than a high-end Garmin Edge on very long ridesSee on Amazon →

Our verdict

Buy the Garmin Edge 840. It is our pick over the Hammerhead Karoo 3: Physical buttons plus touchscreen, handy with gloves and in the rain.

See Garmin Edge 840 on Amazon →
Our pickGarmin Edge 840

Garmin

Garmin Edge 840

Compact GPS cycling computer with mixed button and touchscreen control, and the same performance metrics and routable maps as the Edge 1040 in a smaller body. The high-end pick for riders who don't want a large screen on the bars.

Strengths

  • Physical buttons plus touchscreen, handy with gloves and in the rain
  • Same performance metrics and maps as the Edge 1040 in a compact size
  • Pairs instantly with any ANT+/Bluetooth power meter

Weaknesses

  • Smaller screen: the map is harder to read at descending speed
783,98 €
See Garmin Edge 840 on Amazon →
Hammerhead Karoo 3

Hammerhead

Hammerhead Karoo 3

GPS cycling computer with a smartphone-grade high-resolution touchscreen and the most detailed mapping on the market, with color-coded gradient cues on the route profile. For riders who genuinely navigate and want a phone-like map.

Strengths

  • Bright, sharp touchscreen, the best map experience in the category
  • Color-coded gradient cues on the route profile ahead of every ramp
  • Frequent software updates that keep adding features over time

Weaknesses

  • Shorter battery life than a high-end Garmin Edge on very long rides
434,54 €
See Hammerhead Karoo 3 on Amazon →

Frequently asked questions

Garmin Edge 840 or Hammerhead Karoo 3: which is better?

Buy the Garmin Edge 840. It is our pick over the Hammerhead Karoo 3: Physical buttons plus touchscreen, handy with gloves and in the rain.

When does it make sense to choose Hammerhead Karoo 3?

Choose Hammerhead Karoo 3 if this is what you value most: Bright, sharp touchscreen, the best map experience in the category.

More comparisons

As Amazon Associates we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.